Skip to content

SHOP PRE-ORDERS AVAILABLE NOW!

SHOP PRE-ORDERS AVAILABLE NOW!

HOME
SHOP
TCG SINGLES
EBAY STORE - SPORTS SINGLES
BLACK CAT AUCTIONS
EVERYTHING ELSE
CAT CASH REWARDS PROGRAM

USD

Search

Country/Region

No results found

Search

Country/Region

No results found

Account

Other sign in options Sign in

Orders
Profile

Account

Other sign in options Sign in

Orders
Profile

Your cart is empty

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Continue shopping

SHOP ALL

PRE-ORDERS
SPORTS
- ALL SPORTS
- BASEBALL
- BASKETBALL
- FOOTBALL
- SOCCER
- HOCKEY
TCG
SINGLES

SUPPLIES

BOARD GAMES

PLUSH

Products

Products

EBAY STORE - SPORTS SINGLES

BLACK CAT AUCTIONS

EVERYTHING ELSE

CONTACT US

DISCORD

TCG EVENTS

WARSAW SPORTS & TRADING CARD SHOW

ABOUT US

CAT CASH REWARDS PROGRAM

MAGIC THE GATHERING

Skip to results list

Filters

50 items

Sort

Sort Best selling

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

Column grid

Column grid

Filter

Sort

Sort Best selling

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

MTG: Secret Lair Drop: Dogs Are Better Than Cats - Non-Foil Edition

MTG: Secret Lair Drop: Dogs Are Better Than Cats - Non-Foil Edition

MTG: Secret Lair Drop: Dogs Are Better Than Cats - Non-Foil Edition

$74.99
Commander 2018 Deck - Exquisite Invention

Commander 2018 Deck - Exquisite Invention

Commander 2018 Deck - Exquisite Invention

$54.99

Payment methods

Email

Contact us

Name Email*

Phone Comment

SHOP SHOP

Search

HOURS

SUN 12PM - 5PM

MON 10AM - 2PM

TUE 12PM - 6PM

WED 10AM - 6PM

THUR 10AM - 6PM

FRI 10AM - 7PM

SAT 10AM - 6PM

118 W MARKET ST, WARSAW, IN

574-549-9945

© 2026 Nicodemus Cards & Gaming, Powered by Shopify

Refund policy
Privacy policy
Terms of service
Contact information

Search

Search

Products

1994 Magic the Gathering Legends Life Chisels BGS 9.5

1994 Magic the Gathering Legends Life Chisels BGS 9.5

$149.99
1998 Skybox Marvel: Silver Age Jack Kirby Tribute Spider-Man #JK5 SGC 8

1998 Skybox Marvel: Silver Age Jack Kirby Tribute Spider-Man #JK5 SGC 8

$69.99
20-Pocket Tobacco Card Pages 50ct Pack

20-Pocket Tobacco Card Pages 50ct Pack

$14.99
2007 Marvel Masterpieces SPIDERMAN #79 Gold Border Card Upper Deck PSA 8

2007 Marvel Masterpieces SPIDERMAN #79 Gold Border Card Upper Deck PSA 8

$74.99