ABOUT US...

About Nicodemus Cards & Gaming

What started as a passion project during the COVID-19 quarantine became something much bigger. Nicodemus Cards & Gaming was founded in late 2020, opened its first storefront in Warsaw, Indiana in April 2021, and has since grown into one of the area’s favorite destinations for collectors, players, and hobbyists of all experience levels.

We carry an extensive selection of trading cards — from sports cards spanning baseball, basketball, football, hockey, and soccer, to popular TCGs like Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, One Piece, Lorcana, and Riftbound — plus board games, and all the supplies you need to protect and showcase your collection. We also offer card grading and trading services for collectors looking to buy, sell, or level up their inventory.

But Nicodemus is more than a store. We’re a community hub. Whether you’re here for a tournament, an open play session, or just to talk cards with people who love the hobby as much as you do, you’ll find a welcoming, knowledgeable crew ready to help. We’re proud to serve the collectors of Kosciusko County and beyond — and we’re just getting started.

THE TEAM

Michael Hadley - President
Diana Hadley - Vice President
Mark Liddell - Vice President
John Premetz - Store Manager
Grace Smythe - Events & TCG Trade Coordinator 
Keira Hadley - Sales Associate
Nadia Patton - Sales Associate
Ava Invergo - Sales Associate & Social Media Intern

...plus many more who have helped us along the way in this new journey!